In the trajectory of a startup, there is a dangerous moment when everything seems ready to accelerate: some customers are there, the first income falls, investors are interested in the file, the hires are linked. And yet the product is not ready. The market has not really talked. The model remains fragile. This is the typical moment when we decide to scaler … when we shouldn’t.
This false departure, often made up in the expansion phase, is based on a diagnostic error, Confuse early traction and real product-market. And in a market where capital is rarer, each month of poorly wedged hypercroissance costs expensive. Learning to recognize the False PMF signals has become an imperative of survival.
Partial use is not an adoption
The first trap comes from the use itself. Some customers register, use certain features, renew a subscription. But if we look more closely, the use is intermittent, not very committed, or focused on a single case of secondary use. The product is not yet a reflex. It is not necessary. He is tolerated.
The risk: to take this partial use for a global validation. The Churn begins to go up as soon as the price increases, or a clearer competitor comes into play. The product has won over to the margin, but it has not transformed.
Gross growth often masks structural weakness
Another deceptive signal: growth. A startup can display an increased MRR, dozens of signed customers, a well -filled pipeline … and remain vulnerable. Because this growth was built on noise: sausage marketing paid, aggressive discounts, closings pushed by the founding network. It is quantitative, but not reproducible.
What we observe then is a disproportionate commercial effort compared to the perceived value of the product. The CAC rises without justification, conversion stagnates, the retention is fragile. And the team, overexploited, is exhausted to artificially support a dynamic that does not hold alone.
The customer “who does not understand” is a symptom, not an excuse
In False PMFs, the founder often seeks to re -educate his client rather than listening to it. He is explained, justifies, hopes that “the market will eventually understand”. But in reality, The market is not wrong. He just doesn’t need the product as it is.
The right product does not require excessive pedagogy. It is essential because it solves a real problem, visible, immediate, and better than the alternatives. If the sales cycles stretch, if the prospects hesitate, if the onboarding are long and manual, it is because the problem is not yet resolved – or not painful enough to justify the adoption.
Too many hits, too early
Another sign of a false PMF: premature structuring. From the first contracts, the team expands, the departments are created, the “process” appear. But without stable base, everything becomes unstable. The team produces short after contradictory returns. The dirty sells a constantly changing product. Marketing produces content for a persona that changes each quarter.
This organizational acceleration is based on an illusion: that which the market has spoken, while it still whispers.
The real signs of the right time to scaler
Conversely, some simple indicators indicate that it is time to accelerate:
-
- Customers come back alone, pay without having to revive them, and talk about them around them.
- The churn decreases over the cohorts.
- The sales cycles shorten as the offer stabilizes.
- The product becomes a referent on a precise niche.
- The team can explain in a clear sentence to whom She sells, Why And how.
These signals are not perfect, but their alignment forms a base. As long as they are not united, the scaling is premature.
Scalability does not mean speed
It means repeatability,, predictabilityAnd transfer. A startup that is ticking too early built on sand. It goes into capital, organization, credibility.
The false PMF is a dangerous mirage. It offers the illusion of growth, but hides a systemic fragility. Knowing how to wait, observing, adjusting is not a sign of reluctance, it is the brand of the founders who last.
